Mały teścik ,ciekawe wyniki :)

Testing the on-demand detection of different AV with old malwares.

Hi Guys, I was testing the On-demand detection of different AV with some old malware collections. I will give you the information. But please understand that this malwares are almost 2 years old and there are some more tools in a security products to defend malwares. So, please take the results for informational purpose only. Please don't conclude anything.
Also another problem with the test is that I could not perform the test at the same time. So, a malware which is not detected during my test may be detected now with the updated database. But chances are less because these are already very old samples. Remember I am not an expert. This is a amateur test only.
Tested products until now.
1. Immunet Free
2. Immunet Pro
3. Emsisoft Antimalware
4. Avira Premium
5. SAS Pro
6. MBAM
7. Digital Patrol
8. K7 Antivirus
9. eScan
10. Dr.Web
11. Clam Cloud
12. Digital Defender

P.S: Immunet fails to quarantine almost all threats in an on-demand scan. So, for the free and pro version of Immunet I did the calculation by extracting malwares from an archive. In that way Immunet quarantines threat successfully. Also after that I scanned remaining threats multiple times to ensure that no threat is left which are detected by Immunet.


Please suggest me if you want more products to be included.

Set 1 contains 500 samples.

Immunet free 414/500 (82.8%)
Immunet Pro 495/500 (99%)
Emsisoft Antimalware 500/500 (100%)
Avira Premium 500/500 (100%)
SAS Pro 406/500 (81.2%)
MBAM 471/500 (94.2%)
Digital Patrol 472/500 (94.4%)
K7 441/500 (88.2%)
eScan 493/500 (98.6%)
Dr.Web 445/500 (89%)
Clam Cloud 464/500 (92.8%)
Digital Defender 393/500 (78.6%)


Set 2 contains 5000 samples.

Immunet free 2469/5000 (49.38%)
Immunet Pro 4903/5000 (98.06%)
Emsisoft Antimalware 4986/5000 (99.72%)
Avira Premium 4961/5000 (99.22%)
SAS Pro 223/5000 (4.46%)
MBAM 150/5000 (3%)
Digital Patrol 4829/5000 (96.58%)
K7 3308/5000 (66.16%)
eScan 4718/5000 (94.36%)
Dr.Web 4590/5000 (91.8%)
Clam Cloud 2470/5000 (49.4%)
Digital Defender 3485/5000 (69.7%)

I am disappointed in the performance of Immunet Free and shocked in the success of Digital Patrol. About the inconsistent performance of MBAM and SAS I can say that they are not a full AV.

Update 1: K7 antivirus and eScan added. I used eScan antivirus and software toolkit utility to scan.

Update 2: Added Dr.Web. I used latest version of Cure It to scan.

Update 3: Added Clam Cloud and Digital Defender. Although Clam cloud supposed to have the same technology as Immunet, they have different detection. Thanks to akhil for asking me to test..

Kliknij aby rozwinąć...

polak900 napisał:

wygrał ten produkt co miał największą bazę sygnaturową tak mi się wydaje

Kliknij aby rozwinąć...

Dozamet1 napisał:

dziwny test.Immunet Pro To badziewie a tu taki wynik pff

Kliknij aby rozwinąć...

OXYGEN THIEF napisał:

Dozamet1 napisał:

dziwny test.Immunet Pro To badziewie a tu taki wynik pff

Kliknij aby rozwinąć...

Bo to stare malware i pewnie ma w bazie
Avira i a skwarek vel Emsisoft antimalware Rewelacyjnie

Kliknij aby rozwinąć...